You can never have too many books on your TBR list, and fall is the perfect season to snuggle up with a bunch of the coziest books around. The leaves are golden, the air has a crisp freshness to it, and it feels like the perfect time to start with a new season of books to read. Besides, those pumpkin spice lattes and cozy blankets are calling!

At Once Upon a Book Club, we think of fall as a time filled with comforting stories, magical worlds, and characters who feel like old friends. Whether you're looking to lose yourself in a witchy romance, a heartfelt family tale, or a whimsical adventure, we've gathered 10 cozy books that are perfect for your September reading list. So brew that tea, pull on your fuzzy socks, and let’s get ready for some fall magic.

10 Cozy Reads to Fall Into This Season

 

A Story of Found Family and Autumn Healing 

The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst

Let’s kick things off with a romantic and heartwarming tale. This stunning hardcover with its lavender-sprayed edges is pure cottagecore joy, filled with stolen spellbooks, sweet jam, and the most charming sentient spider plant you’ll ever meet. 

Kiela, a shy librarian, escapes revolution by fleeing to her childhood island, where she opens a secret spell shop and discovers friendship, love, and the power of second chances. It’s like a warm cinnamon bun of a book, and an ideal start to your cozy fall novel collection.

A Small-Town Romance Set Against Changing Leaves

The Pumpkin Spice Café by Laurie Gilmore

Small towns, grumpy farmers, and pumpkin spice lattes, just what we called for! Jeanie inherits a café and a fresh start, while Logan, the grumpy-but-gorgeous local farmer, wants none of it…or does he? 

With a guaranteed happily ever after and all the fall feels, this book is the literary equivalent of a flannel blanket and crackling fireplace. Add it to your cozy fall book rotation and sip along with your favorite spiced brew.

Magical Realism That Warms the Soul

A Constellation of Roses by Miranda Asebedo

Trix McCabe has been on the run until she lands in the arms of her magical, long-lost family. Think enchanted pies, secrets that whisper themselves into the air, and healing through belonging. 

If you’re into stories where magic meets emotional depth, this one’s for you. A rich, character-driven tale that feels like coming home. You may just want to pair this with our Self-Love Box for double the heart-healing.

A Reflective, Nostalgic Journey of Self-Discovery

A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers

A tea monk meets a robot, and together they explore what it means to be human in a world where technology and nature coexist in harmony. 

This beautifully slow and meditative story is ideal for when you're craving something that’s equal parts hopeful and philosophical. It’s the ultimate fall read: warm, wise, and quietly profound.

A Whimsical Tale of Magic, Love, and Belonging

The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna

Mika Moon is used to being alone…until she breaks all the rules and finds a quirky household in need of a witchy tutor. With three magical children, one broody librarian (swoon), and a house full of secrets, this warm and witty novel reminds us that family is what you make it. You will definitely want to add this to your September cozy book lineup and get ready to be charmed.

 

An Orc, a Dream, and a Coffee Shop

Legends & Lattes by Travis Baldree

Viv the orc has retired from a life of blood and battles to open a café. What follows is a slice-of-life fantasy full of cinnamon rolls, unlikely friendships, and self-reinvention. 

It’s a low-stakes, high-heart story that will warm your soul like a freshly baked scone. Calling all fans of cozy adult books!

A Whimsical Bookish Adventure With Heart

The Wishing Game by Meg Shaffer

A reclusive author. A life-changing competition. A woman chasing her dream to adopt a child she loves. With elements of whimsy, heartbreak, and second chances, The Wishing Game is a book lover’s dream. 

The literary references, the magical island, and the found family—this book has everything. We featured this fabulous novel in our exclusive Teacher Box, and trust us, it’s unforgettable.

A Hug in Novel Form 

The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune

When caseworker Linus is sent to assess a mysterious orphanage for magical children, he discovers a world of love, found family, and courage. 

This heart-melting tale is full of tender moments and gentle reminders to embrace the unusual. This one is ideal for fans of warm fall books; it’s the kind of story that stays with you long after the last leaf has fallen.

A Hexy, Swoony Rom-Com for the Spooky Season

The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling

Vivi accidentally cursed her ex. Whoops. Now he’s back in town, the ley lines are a mess, and the ghost of her heartbreak won’t stay buried. Spooky, sassy, and just the right amount of sexy, The Ex Hex is perfect for anyone looking for a magical rom-com with autumn vibes and a talking cat. 

One Last Adventure in the Pumpkin Patch

Pumpkinheads by Rainbow Rowell & Faith Erin Hicks

A graphic novel that will tug at your heartstrings and make you crave caramel apples. Deja and Josiah are seasonal best friends working their final Halloween shift at the world’s best pumpkin patch. What follows is a sweet, funny, nostalgic whirlwind of snacks, surprises, and what-ifs. If you’re looking for cozy books to read in September, this one’s a delight.

 

How to Make Fall Reading Extra Cozy

Let’s be honest: a cozy book deserves a cozy setting. Light your favorite fall-scented candle, grab your fluffy robe and socks, and sip something deliciously warm. As you know, we’re all about detail, and this fall we think accessorizing is the ultimate indulgence. Our Boutique is your one-stop shop for all your bookish needs. 

We are loving our cream-colored “Ask Me What I’m Reading” book sleeves with their elegant purple font. These book sleeves also feature an incredibly soft, vegan leather exterior with an elastic pen/highlighter holder, a small, zippered pocket on the back, an extra-large (think Crescent City, two-to-three paperbacks, or a 10" tablet + a book) lined interior, and an elastic button closure at the top.

And let’s not forget about our incredible phone case covers. Pure bookish delight! We have endless design options, and we think you will love this exclusively designed phone case inspired by Mary Poppins, by P. L. Travers. This adorable phone case features a floral design on the front cover with the silhouette of Mary Poppins flying with her umbrella and bag over the London skyline. The back of the phone case features a stack of tea cups and the quote, "Practically perfect in every way."

Let the Pages Fall Where They May

Fall is about slowing down, savoring the moment, and diving deep into stories that touch the soul. These cozy fall books aren’t just page-turners; they’re companions for those quiet nights, hot drinks, and all the feelings that come with changing seasons. Speaking of hot drinks, you will definitely want to check out our blog, The Ultimate Cozy Night In: Pairing Books with Hot Drinks!

So whether you’re exploring our Adult Book Subscription Boxes or browsing through our Ready-to-Ship Book Boxes, let OUABC bring the magic right to your doorstep. Happy reading from all of us at Once Upon a Book Club!